How we structure a sugar transaction, and what protects the buyer at each step
How a physical sugar transaction is structured, from LOI to payment, and why each stage exists to protect both sides.
By Hugo Amanajás
So that both sides work from the same understanding, we set out here how our sugar operations are structured, why each stage exists, and what protects the buyer at each point. Most disputes in this market come from parties operating under different assumptions about sequence. The intent here is to remove that risk. The full procedure is also published on our Procedures page.
The principle behind the process
A physical commodity transaction is a chain of conditional steps. Neither party is asked to expose value before the counterparty has committed something of equivalent weight. We do not ask the buyer to open a banking instrument before there is a signed contract; the buyer does not ask us to expose our origin before that contract exists.
Each document opens the next, and nothing advances until the prior condition is formally met. This is not bureaucracy. It is what keeps either side from carrying a risk the other has not yet matched.
The documentary sequence
The sequence below is the backbone of the operation. Each stage gates the next.
- 01LOI
Letter of Intent
Issued by the buyer. A formal statement of interest: product, ICUMSA grade, monthly volume, contract duration, destination port, delivery basis and intended terms, with the full details of the end buyer. It is non-binding. It shows the demand is real and lets us test feasibility against origin availability.
- 02NCNDA
Non-circumvention & non-disclosure agreement
Signed by both parties before any introduction or technical detail. It protects both positions equally and is the instrument that allows the conversation to become specific.
- 03FCO
Full Corporate Offer
Issued by us. A firm offer: contractual specification, price, Incoterm under Incoterms 2020, shipment schedule, payment terms and validity. It is the document the buyer evaluates commercially.
- 04ICPO
Irrevocable Corporate Purchase Order
Issued by the buyer. A firm acceptance of the offer, on letterhead and with banking coordinates. It confirms that the parties are moving to contract.
- 05IMFPA
Master fee protection agreement
Secures the intermediaries' fees, paid out of the transaction and not from the buyer's side of the price. It removes any incentive for anyone in the chain to distort terms.
- 06SPA
Sale & Purchase Agreement
The binding contract. It fixes specification, tolerance, quantity, delivery basis, schedule, inspection framework, documentary package, payment mechanism, guarantees, remedies for default, force majeure and governing law. Everything before it is preparatory. The buyer's legal and compliance teams should review it in full before signing.
- 07DLC / SBLC
Payment instrument
Issued by the buyer after the SPA is signed. The buyer's bank issues the instrument in our favour: a first-tier bank, operative under UCP 600, payable against presentation of conforming documents.
- 08PB
Performance bond
Issued by us. With the instrument operative, we issue a performance bond in the buyer's favour, usually two per cent of the contract value, as per contract. From that point, both obligations are secured.
- 09SGS / Intertek
Inspection at loading
Independent verification of quality, quantity and packaging against the contractual specification, carried out on the buyer's cargo by SGS or Intertek. The buyer may nominate the agency, and the scope is agreed in the contract.
- 10CAD
Shipment & payment against documents
The cargo is shipped, the documentary set is presented to the bank, and payment is released only against documents conforming to the letter of credit.
LOI → NCNDA → FCO → ICPO → IMFPA → SPA → DLC/SBLC → performance bond → inspection → shipment → payment
Origin protection
This is the point where we do not vary, and we prefer to state it plainly now rather than let it become an obstacle later. Until the SPA is signed and the payment instrument and our guarantee are in place, we release no document or material that identifies the mill or refinery, its registration numbers, its location or the specific loading terminal.
This includes Bills of Lading, certificates of analysis, phytosanitary or origin certificates, warehouse or tank receipts, mill letterhead, plant registration numbers, and photographs of product, warehouse or transport.
It applies equally to documents from earlier shipments, for a reason that works in the buyer's favour: those documents belong to other buyers. Releasing them would breach our obligations to those parties. Once the buyer is under contract, their documents receive exactly the same protection. A desk that shows one party's document will show the buyer's to the next enquiry it receives.
/ A practical point
In this market, recycled and forged Bills of Lading and inspection reports circulate in very large volume. A past shipment document proves nothing about the cargo the buyer will receive, even when authentic. The verification with real value is done on the buyer's own cargo, at loading, by the agency the buyer nominates.
Once the contract and instruments are in place, nothing is withheld. The origin is disclosed to the buyer and to their inspection agency, and the buyer receives the complete documentary set for their cargo: certificate of origin, certificate of analysis, phytosanitary certificate, packing list, insurance certificate where applicable, and the Bill of Lading.
How the buyer's position is protected
The buyer is not asked to trust a document. The buyer is asked to trust a structure:
- Documentary payment: funds do not leave the buyer's bank until conforming documents are presented and verified under UCP 600; if they do not conform, the bank does not pay.
- Independent inspection of the buyer's cargo, by the agency the buyer nominates, against the specification written into the contract.
- Our performance secured by a bond, callable if we fail after the instrument is operative.
- A contract reviewed by the buyer's lawyer before any commitment.
Non-performance costs us. It does not cost the buyer.
What we need from the buyer
We work only with disclosed principals. Undisclosed multi-broker chains are not worked, in any direction. To advance, we need:
- A signed LOI on letterhead, with the full details of the end buyer;
- Corporate documents and the signatory's passport, for KYC;
- Confirmation of the issuing bank for the DLC or SBLC.
On receipt of these, we counter-sign the NCNDA and issue the FCO.
/ In short
If any part of the above is unclear, or if the buyer's compliance needs the sequence adapted to internal requirements, we address it directly. We would rather settle the structure now than discover a misalignment after commitments are made.
The full documentary procedure referenced here is published on our Procedures page.
View Procedures/ About the author
Hugo Amanajás
Hugo Amanajás is an engineer and commodities broker, and the founder of Juros e Bolsa, a CVM-authorised investment advisory in Brazil. He works on the origination and structuring of Brazilian commodities and writes Duna Trading's Insights on how the physical trade actually works, from documentary procedure to compliance.
LinkedIn