How sugar is priced: the benchmark, the white premium, and the differentials
A sugar price is never a number a seller invented. It is built from a global benchmark and a set of adjustments. Learn the parts and you can read a quote in a minute.
By Hugo Amanajás
A sugar price is never just a number a seller invented. It is built from a global benchmark, a premium for refining, and a set of adjustments for exactly what is being shipped and how. A buyer who knows how the price is assembled can tell a serious quote from a fantasy one in about a minute.
The two benchmarks
Raw sugar prices off the New York No. 11 futures contract. Refined white sugar prices off the London No. 5 contract. The gap between them is the white premium, the market's price for turning raw sugar into refined. When someone quotes ICUMSA 45, the London No. 5 sits in the background as the reference, and the white premium is one of the first things a knowledgeable buyer checks.
From benchmark to your price
- The benchmark futures level for the shipment month.
- The white premium, for refined grades.
- The origin differential: what Brazilian sugar trades at against the benchmark, which moves with freight, harvest and demand.
- Polarisation and quality premiums or discounts, since a spec above or below standard is worth more or less.
- The Incoterm: an FOB price and a CIF price are not comparable until you add the freight and insurance.
Why a price with no basis is a red flag
This is the practical payoff. A quote that sits far below the benchmark plus a normal differential is not a bargain waiting for you. It is a signal. Either the seller does not know the market, or the cargo is not real. A genuine offer can always be traced back to the benchmark and the differentials, and a genuine seller can explain how the number was built. Ask. The answer tells you who you are dealing with.
/ You can sanity-check a sugar price yourself
You do not need a trading desk. You need the current No. 11 or No. 5 level, the rough origin differential, and the Incoterm. If a quote cannot be reconciled to those three, treat the quote, and the counterparty, with caution.
The full documentary procedure referenced here is published on our Procedures page.
View Procedures/ About the author
Hugo Amanajás
Hugo Amanajás is an engineer and commodities broker, and the founder of Juros e Bolsa, a CVM-authorised investment advisory in Brazil. He works on the origination and structuring of Brazilian commodities and writes Duna Trading's Insights on how the physical trade actually works, from documentary procedure to compliance.
LinkedIn